Table 3
Comparison between Liulin observation data and prediction model data of NAIRAS, CARI-6M, and KREAM
| Liulin-6K (A) (μSv) | NAIRAS (B) (μSv) | Error(%, 100× ((B A)/A)) | CARI-6M (C) (μSv) | Error (%, 100× ((C A)/A)) | KREAM (D) (μSv) | Error (%, 100× ((D A)/A)) |
1 | 61.32 | 101.09 | 64.86 | 68.75 | 12.12 | 56.87 | –7.26 |
2 | 56.50 | 98.61 | 74.53 | 67.24 | 19.01 | 51.01 | –9.72 |
3 | 102.82 | 137.25 | 33.49 | 82.49 | –19.77 | 76.25 | –25.84 |
4 | 84.00 | 120.63 | 43.61 | 70.96 | –15.52 | 84.78 | 0.93 |
5 | 80.60 | - | - | - | - | 71.26 | –11.59 |
6 | 81.79 | 121.02 | 47.96 | 69.70 | –14.78 | 80.53 | –1.54 |
7 | 52.44 | 101.09 | 92.77 | 68.75 | 31.10 | 49.82 | –5.00 |
8 | 6.10 | - | - | - | - | 7.87 | 29.02 |
9 | 47.18 | 66.18 | 40.27 | 44.62 | –5.43 | 46.77 | –0.87 |
10 | 25.19 | 23.20 | –7.90 | 27.44 | 8.93 | 23.88 | –5.20 |
11 | 54.36 | 42.87 | –21.14 | 31.93 | –41.26 | 44.72 | –17.73 |
12 | 70.72 | 120.69 | 70.66 | 72.74 | 2.86 | 62.31 | –11.89 |
13 | 95.65 | 120.35 | 25.82 | 52.91 | –44.68 | 75.14 | –21.44 |
14 | 116.73 | 131.86 | 12.96 | 71.55 | –38.70 | 104.15 | –10.78 |
15 | 55.59 | 73.41 | 32.06 | 53.37 | –3.99 | 47.18 | –15.13 |
16 | 15.46 | - | - | - | - | 15.49 | 0.19 |
17 | 55.51 | 98.61 | 77.64 | 67.24 | 21.13 | 53.44 | –3.73 |
18 | 62.04 | 42.87 | –30.90 | 31.93 | –48.53 | 48.39 | –22.00 |
19 | 90.05 | 120.69 | 34.03 | 72.74 | –19.22 | 72.31 | –19.70 |
20 | 83.95 | 101.09 | 20.42 | 68.75 | –18.11 | 71.18 | –15.21 |
21 | 67.87 | 98.61 | 45.29 | 67.24 | –0.93 | 57.07 | –15.91 |
22 | 11.16 | 5.85 | –47.58 | 13.28 | 19.00 | 10.28 | –7.89 |
23 | 10.96 | 6.29 | –42.61 | 16.82 | 53.47 | 10.48 | –4.38 |
24 | 75.50 | 137.25 | 81.79 | 82.49 | 9.26 | 74.90 | –0.79 |
25 | 113.73 | 120.63 | 6.07 | 70.96 | –37.61 | 102.31 | –10.04 |
|
Average error | | | 43.38 | | 22.06 | | 10.95 |